Sunday, 30 December 2018

MY truth about solo travelling as a female in India

Disclaimer; explicit language and discussion about sex, sexuality, sexual violence etc.

My own - in this case very humble - opinion about what it is like to travel solo as a female in India is that the topic is quite infected and not very seldom the discussion is taken over by either extremely privileged ladies who have the means to stay very safe by means of money or by men(!) who feel they can say that it is absolutely 100 percent safe for foreign women to travel solo in India. Now, when re-telling one's experiences of doing something I believe it is very important to point out from which perspective one is writing, because no one's experience is invalid just because it is different from somebody else's, there are so many factors that influence what the experience of solo travelling in India will be like. So many intersecting factors to use a fancier word. I can only recount my own experience(s) and what it is like and has been like in the past. My experiences are influenced by the fact that I am from north Europe and I have quite northern European features, meaning that it is very obvious that I am white; there is absolutely no ambiguity in regard to this. Now, everyone should know what being white entails in regard to privilege - especially white people! Unfortunately, of course, this is not always the case. As always I like to quote one of my favourite feminist scholars of all time; María Lugones (in tight competition with Chandra Talpade Mohanty, Judith Butler and Jasbir Puar), who has taken huge responsibility when it comes to writing on white privilege (come on white feminist scholars! Is it not actually our responsibility to also write on this and not always kind of overlook our own positionality? Is it due to the mentality of "I cannot really feel it, so I don't like to think about it?"). But anyways, this quote by Lugones is illustrative of what it is all about even though it is not explicitly about what white privilege translates to in practice (I know that Lugones' language is not always very accessible, but please try and read her):

Infantilisation of judgment is a form of ethnocentric racism precisely because it is a self-indulgent denial of one's understanding of one's culture and its expressing racism. One of the features of this denial is the denial that racism is a two-party affair, an interactive phenomenon. In infantilization of judgment, the racist attempts to hide that she understands racism as a participant.

Infantilization is broken if one squarely and respectfully sets the white/Anglo inquirer in the position of seeing herself as a competent practitioner of her culture and a racialized member of the racial state and if one also blocks the possibility of escape into lack of engagement. She cannot then take refuge into incompetence, for this presupposes that racialization and the having of a culture are what happens to others who are not her people and whom she can know only abstractly. One cannot disown one's culture. One can reconstruct it in struggle (from Lugones-Pilgrimages/Peregrinajes 2003:114-115)
Now, I believe that ideally, any white westerner who travel to the non-west should be aware of their privilege and how this privilege historically has come about and what the consequences are when one "enjoys" such privilege. Why? Well, because I have witnessed all too many times white westerners in India who don't realise why they are perceived a certain way and they also think that a certain admiration for their culture, lifestyle etc. stems from the fact that their culture, lifestyle etc. are objectively superior. This is of course a grave error in thinking; admiration is subjective. In this case stemming from what has become, through years and years of complex systems of oppression by the global north of the global south, starting with the colonisation of the world - an intersubjective and highly eurocentric "truth". Now, a "truth" that is intersubjective is not true, it is not an opinion either because it has informed everything that we do, every single "performance", our perception and language to such an extent that we (except maybe for some uncontacted tribes) cannot think outside those very unflexible frames. There is no truth in light skin being more beautiful than dark skin. There is no truths to be found in the high profits in skin lightening industry, the profits are only proof that the intersubjective idea that light skin is more attractive than dark skin is extremely pervasive.

"Why should the skin lightening industry concern a white westerner anyway?" you may ask. Well, it should because you should realise that this particular part of your appearance has become hailed as being the ideal - I dare say - everywhere in the world. The fact that tanning is popular in majority white countries doesn't change this. You will still be a white person with a tan. This doesn't by any means mean that you are superior or that you deserve being "the ideal". It means though, that you will receive treatment from others that might make you feel that you are superior and eventually you will get so used to it that you don't even think about it. Therefore you must think about it and as I always keep nagging on about; YOU HAVE TO USE YOUR PRIVILEGE IN A GOOD WAY WHEN YOU CAN! OTHERWISE YOU ARE COMPLICIT IN WHATEVER "-ISM" IS HAPPENING! So that when you, as a white person get served before someone who is brown or black in a restaurant or store or whatever, you should say "NO! I am sorry, but these people were here before me, you should serve them first!". This applies equally to any type of privilege; male privilege, Christian privilege, cis-gender privilege, heterosexual privilege etc.

I believe this is important to point out before starting to talk about the practicalities of solo travelling for females in India. I am white. Because I am white and even more so perhaps because of the additional nationality privilege of having a Swedish passport I receive treatment in India that cannot - to any extent - be compared to the treatment that, for example, black female solo travellers receive in India (to see an example of this you can read this article - click!). Yes, if you are a foreigner who look different from the majority of the local population you will receive a lot of attention in many parts of India. My experience is also that compared to for example Sweden, where private space is almost sacred, is that in India most people don't shy away from getting close to you (at least not men), be it in a physical or emotional way. Sure, in Sweden people would also look at something they consider "different" but they would do it discreetly and from a distance. So in case you are an introvert like me and consider to go to India; be prepared for the fact that you will, unlike you do in Sweden, not enjoy a huge amount of privacy in public spaces. Strangers will talk to you (oh mother of god, that's scary! most Swedes would probably say in response to that), they will ask you questions that will seem intrusive from your perspective and they will look at you. You better just get used to it. You don't have to answer questions that you find intrusive, but sometimes it might be useful to answer strangers with a lie (especially as a solo female traveller when it comes to questions about your love life; it is okay to say you are married, have a boyfriend or whatever even if it is not true if it will make an intrusive person back off). In short, don't expect this when you come to India (especially you Swedes):

(Source: google)

When I am about to go to India I always receive the same type of comments from family, friends, acquaintances etc. and that is: "be careful!", "do you have to go?", "is it not very dangerous for women in India?" and other comments along the same lines. Now, I hate it when people sugarcoat it just because they haven't had bad experiences, which reminds me of this cartoon:

(credit to Christine Rai. Insta handle: @yeahitschill)

This is important to remember. I have heard so many white women in India saying that "oooh, but India is so safe! I mean, the rape statistics are higher in the US than in India". Hey lady, wake up! Are you stupid? There are reasons why India is a country frequenting lists over the world's most dangerous countries for women (and often lands in the top 3 or even number 1) and if you remove your head from your ass and look at the facts you might be able to understand why that is so. It doesn't have to do with you and just because you have the means to stay at mid-range or high-end places, have daily coffees at Starbucks, to travel in the AC-section at trains or by domestic flight and you have a bathroom ensuite does not mean that the majority of the women who actually live in India live under the same circumstances. Also, do not even get me started on the rape statistics. Just because the rape stats in Sweden are higher than in India doesn't mean that there are more rapes per capita in Sweden. We cannot know that for sure, but it is highly unlikely that the case is that. The more likely explanations for this is that, for example, many cases that would clearly legally count as rape in Sweden does not legally qualify as rape in India, corruption is almost non-existent in Sweden whilst in India corruption is rampant, in India honour culture is much stronger than it usually is in Sweden which means that it is more likely that a rape victim will try to hide the fact that they have been raped because revealing it might have very bad implications for their futures, there is a much higher trust towards state authorities in Sweden than in India (see corruption) etc. 

Also, in regard to these lists over countries that are unsafe for women; it is highly unlikely that tourists that come to India will be subjected to human trafficking, that they will be subjected to so-called dowry murders, that they will be subjected to rape in police custody, that they will have to make dangerous commutes to make their living, that they will be forced into marriage at an early age, that they will be subjected to female foeticide/infanticide, etc. This does NOT mean that India is a safe country for women, what it means though is that India is a relatively safe country for relatively "well off" people in general and for (especially white) female tourists; even solo female tourists. Saying that India is generally safe for women though is like being white and saying that racism does not exist. I believe that it is extremely important to be aware of this and to not brush off these things just because you happened to be able to walk safely home at night in a gated community in Bombay or Bangalore once or twice. 

So what I will say about India is instead this; as a white solo female traveller (with the additional privilege of sometimes being able to pass off as a man, which is convenient especially during over night travelling) India is not more unsafe than most countries. However, I would say that it is highly advisable to practice caution. I can only compare it to what it is like to live in Sweden which is often ranked at the other end of the spectrum when it comes to safety for women. But what I would generally say is that consent and the feeling of entitlement is a big thing when it comes to differences between the two countries. I have been groped several times in India, a man grabbed me between my legs on a train between Amritsar and Delhi, a young boy(!) grabbed my boobs on a beach in Goa, I do experience sexual harassment on the streets almost on a daily basis in some parts of India (mainly touristy places) and I have received some very inappropriate requests from random men (in the style of just walking up and saying "hey, come to my place and have sex with me!" and this particular thing is probably due to the fact that the stereotype about white ladies is that we will quite simply drop our pants at "hello"). I am quite tough on the streets in India, way tougher than in Sweden, because it is necessary. And, a simple "no" is quite often not enough if a man has decided that he wants to talk to you/have sex with you or whatever. This is true all over the world though, that men feel that they are somehow entitled to receive undivided attention from women. Why? (Hold on to your hats, here it comes....!!!) it is spelled P A T R I A R C H Y, which is the societal system in which men are believed to be superior to women. The symptoms being so many that it requires a book thicker than the bible just in list form. No society is non-patriarchal. India is just some notches higher on the patriarchy level than for example Sweden. Patriarchy teaches men and boys that they are entitled and women and girls that they are not entitled but that they are supposed to abide. What are some of the results? Different forms of violence against women, controlling of women, not the least controlling of women's reproductive systems that lead to honour cultures, etc.

So in regard to privilege again. I will not recommend anyone to do anything they feel uncomfortable with or simply does not want to do. I have the physial prowess as well as the actual means to say no to patriarchy in many cases. Many times I can spit back when the patriarchy spits in my face so to speak. I can go to India and I can stay in a gated community and just wave my Swedish passport in people's faces. I have the means to get informed and not be just an aesthetic feminist and buy in to shit like this: 

(From Insta handle: @activislam)

But, it is equally important to recognise that not everybody has the privileges that you have. Now, you might think that you are showing more respect towards the people of the country or countries that you are visiting by refusing to see that there are bad sides as well. In that case you could not be more wrong. By only seeing what is "good" you are only doing the most privileged people in that particular society a favour. No country, no society, no community in the world is free from hierarchies. If you say that everything about India is phenomenal and beautiful you risk doing what so many westerners are doing: appropriating Indian culture (see earlier post about e.g. rude British lady with Ganesh tattoo on her left hand - still want to point out that it is not my place to get offended about that) and hailing everything about it without being properly informed, buying into the history of the country that eradicates more marginal communities and overlooks dissident/opposition sentiment and you also risk to render the lived experiences of certain communities completely invisible. You will not see the fact that India has an extremely diverse and vibrant civil society (a civil society that unfortunately is under acute as well as longstanding threat, suffice it to say as much, which says quite a lot), full of people with plenty of agency, which is probably the biggest strength of the country and why I love India so f*cking much and keep coming back here. To sound extremely pompous: the strength of India is in the people. The strength of India is in all of the people. I don't want anyone missing out on India, I don't want anyone missing out on any part of India because it might be uncomfortable to look at or because there are certain people that will not want you to see it. 

(I also want to point out, to be perfectly clear, that I do NOT claim to have a "full picture" of India or that I have seen "all of India" but I think you get the gist of what I am trying to say)

No comments:

Post a Comment